“市場(chǎng)先生”是傳奇價(jià)值投資人本杰明·格雷厄姆創(chuàng)作的一個(gè)著名虛擬人物,,自然也有著股票市場(chǎng)經(jīng)常出現(xiàn)的反常、非理性和精神錯(cuò)亂的行為,。
格雷厄姆和他的門(mén)徒沃倫·巴菲特時(shí)常會(huì)津津樂(lè)道地談起“市場(chǎng)先生”,,比如他的情緒是如何從瘋狂迷戀轉(zhuǎn)變成無(wú)謂恐懼的,,即從抬高股票定價(jià),,到最終突然暴跌,。他們認(rèn)為,,在熱情和暴怒這兩種情緒之間,,“市場(chǎng)先生”能夠表現(xiàn)出良好的判斷力。
當(dāng)然,,“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于股票的估值,更多體現(xiàn)在他對(duì)未來(lái)收益的看法,。過(guò)去七周,,在新型冠狀病毒的影響下,,“市場(chǎng)先生”突然經(jīng)歷了最近一段時(shí)間以來(lái)最極端的情緒波動(dòng),,可以看出他對(duì)利潤(rùn)預(yù)期做出了大幅調(diào)整。
自從“市場(chǎng)先生”的前景變得更加樂(lè)觀以來(lái),,他就一直在兜售合理或者更高的基準(zhǔn)收益率,。但當(dāng)新冠疫情來(lái)臨,他還能否接受下行市場(chǎng)中的收益率水平,?
只要我們能判斷出“市場(chǎng)先生”相去甚遠(yuǎn)的精神狀態(tài)中,,哪一種狀態(tài)對(duì)于收益率水平而言是最合理的,我們就能確定股票的合理估值,。
我們用標(biāo)普500指數(shù)來(lái)代表“市場(chǎng)先生”。2月19日,,標(biāo)普指數(shù)漲至史上最高點(diǎn)3386點(diǎn),根據(jù)四個(gè)季度的往績(jī)利潤(rùn)計(jì)算,,每股收益為139.47美元?!笆袌?chǎng)先生”洋洋自得,盡管這種心態(tài)沒(méi)有任何道理。市盈率為24.3倍,,比近1/4世紀(jì)約20倍的平均市盈率還高出22%,。每股收益達(dá)到歷史最高點(diǎn),但由于收入在其中所占的超高比例,,因此它同時(shí)也處于近似泡沫化的水平。
不久后,,新冠疫情的爆發(fā)使“市場(chǎng)先生”陷入了恐慌,。3月23日,,標(biāo)普指數(shù)下跌至2237點(diǎn),跌幅高達(dá)33.9%,。當(dāng)時(shí)“市場(chǎng)先生”是如何看待利潤(rùn)前景的?他的觀點(diǎn)正確嗎,?
“市場(chǎng)先生”在二月中旬使用的溢價(jià)倍數(shù),表明了當(dāng)時(shí)市場(chǎng)正處在一種自我滿足的狀態(tài),。但疫情的爆發(fā)動(dòng)搖了“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于未來(lái)的信心,。為了表達(dá)這種焦慮的心情,,他采用了更低的市盈率,相當(dāng)于近幾十年來(lái)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)水平,,即20倍左右,。按照這個(gè)市盈率計(jì)算,,在3月23日的低點(diǎn),,標(biāo)普500指數(shù)的每股收益穩(wěn)定在111.18美元。
3月23日之后,,“市場(chǎng)先生”擺脫了恐懼,,變得“情緒高漲”。截至4月9日收盤(pán)時(shí),,標(biāo)普指數(shù)已經(jīng)收復(fù)了近半失地,,暴漲557點(diǎn)至2794點(diǎn),漲幅25%,,成為該指數(shù)史上六次最大三周漲幅之一,。
“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于每股收益的態(tài)度,也自然而然地從沮喪突然變得無(wú)所不知,。當(dāng)市盈率達(dá)到20倍,,標(biāo)普指數(shù)在2794點(diǎn)時(shí),每股收益為139.70美元,。深呼吸吧“市場(chǎng)先生”,,這與今年早些時(shí)候標(biāo)普指數(shù)處在歷史高點(diǎn)時(shí)的每股收益139.47美元相差無(wú)幾。就連華爾街的幻想家們也不敢這樣癡心妄想,。
診斷:“市場(chǎng)先生”可能瘋了,。
市場(chǎng)跌至低谷時(shí)的111美元每股收益看起來(lái)相當(dāng)合理,這與經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)家羅伯特·席勒的周期調(diào)整后市盈率水平相當(dāng),。CAPE使用十年平均水平,,消除了利潤(rùn)異常波動(dòng)帶來(lái)的影響。換言之,,CAPE把“市場(chǎng)先生”扮演成了一位性情溫和的紳士,。
“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于市盈率的情緒波動(dòng)告訴我們,2237點(diǎn)最低點(diǎn)與今天的2794點(diǎn)相比,,前者的股票價(jià)格才是更公允的估值,。路孚特調(diào)查時(shí)發(fā)現(xiàn),華爾街分析師預(yù)測(cè)第2季度的每股收益將比去年同期下降19.4%,。但今年晚些時(shí)候或者2021年,,每股收益會(huì)出現(xiàn)反彈。對(duì)于股市而言,,重要的不是它們會(huì)如何反彈,,而是在反彈開(kāi)始之后,它們將穩(wěn)定在什么水平,。
每股收益111美元雖然比歷史最高點(diǎn)減少了五分之一,卻是比較合理的估算,。但這個(gè)數(shù)字也值得警醒,。假如標(biāo)普指數(shù)繼續(xù)將60%的收益用于發(fā)放股息和回購(gòu),,并將另外40%進(jìn)行再投資用于企業(yè)發(fā)展,每股收益將在111美元基礎(chǔ)上每年增長(zhǎng)約5%,。這需要四年半時(shí)間才能重新達(dá)到此前每股140美元的最高點(diǎn),。
在三月末跌入低谷的時(shí)候,“市場(chǎng)先生”其實(shí)非常理智,。只是他自己不知道而已,。(財(cái)富中文網(wǎng))
譯者:Biz
“市場(chǎng)先生”是傳奇價(jià)值投資人本杰明·格雷厄姆創(chuàng)作的一個(gè)著名虛擬人物,自然也有著股票市場(chǎng)經(jīng)常出現(xiàn)的反常,、非理性和精神錯(cuò)亂的行為,。
格雷厄姆和他的門(mén)徒沃倫·巴菲特時(shí)常會(huì)津津樂(lè)道地談起“市場(chǎng)先生”,比如他的情緒是如何從瘋狂迷戀轉(zhuǎn)變成無(wú)謂恐懼的,,即從抬高股票定價(jià),,到最終突然暴跌。他們認(rèn)為,,在熱情和暴怒這兩種情緒之間,,“市場(chǎng)先生”能夠表現(xiàn)出良好的判斷力。
當(dāng)然,,“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于股票的估值,,更多體現(xiàn)在他對(duì)未來(lái)收益的看法。過(guò)去七周,,在新型冠狀病毒的影響下,,“市場(chǎng)先生”突然經(jīng)歷了最近一段時(shí)間以來(lái)最極端的情緒波動(dòng),可以看出他對(duì)利潤(rùn)預(yù)期做出了大幅調(diào)整,。
自從“市場(chǎng)先生”的前景變得更加樂(lè)觀以來(lái),,他就一直在兜售合理或者更高的基準(zhǔn)收益率。但當(dāng)新冠疫情來(lái)臨,,他還能否接受下行市場(chǎng)中的收益率水平,?
只要我們能判斷出“市場(chǎng)先生”相去甚遠(yuǎn)的精神狀態(tài)中,哪一種狀態(tài)對(duì)于收益率水平而言是最合理的,,我們就能確定股票的合理估值,。
我們用標(biāo)普500指數(shù)來(lái)代表“市場(chǎng)先生”。2月19日,,標(biāo)普指數(shù)漲至史上最高點(diǎn)3386點(diǎn),,根據(jù)四個(gè)季度的往績(jī)利潤(rùn)計(jì)算,每股收益為139.47美元,?!笆袌?chǎng)先生”洋洋自得,盡管這種心態(tài)沒(méi)有任何道理,。市盈率為24.3倍,,比近1/4世紀(jì)約20倍的平均市盈率還高出22%,。每股收益達(dá)到歷史最高點(diǎn),但由于收入在其中所占的超高比例,,因此它同時(shí)也處于近似泡沫化的水平,。
不久后,新冠疫情的爆發(fā)使“市場(chǎng)先生”陷入了恐慌,。3月23日,,標(biāo)普指數(shù)下跌至2237點(diǎn),跌幅高達(dá)33.9%,。當(dāng)時(shí)“市場(chǎng)先生”是如何看待利潤(rùn)前景的,?他的觀點(diǎn)正確嗎?
“市場(chǎng)先生”在二月中旬使用的溢價(jià)倍數(shù),,表明了當(dāng)時(shí)市場(chǎng)正處在一種自我滿足的狀態(tài),。但疫情的爆發(fā)動(dòng)搖了“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于未來(lái)的信心。為了表達(dá)這種焦慮的心情,,他采用了更低的市盈率,,相當(dāng)于近幾十年來(lái)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)水平,即20倍左右,。按照這個(gè)市盈率計(jì)算,,在3月23日的低點(diǎn),標(biāo)普500指數(shù)的每股收益穩(wěn)定在111.18美元,。
3月23日之后,,“市場(chǎng)先生”擺脫了恐懼,變得“情緒高漲”,。截至4月9日收盤(pán)時(shí),,標(biāo)普指數(shù)已經(jīng)收復(fù)了近半失地,暴漲557點(diǎn)至2794點(diǎn),,漲幅25%,,成為該指數(shù)史上六次最大三周漲幅之一。
“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于每股收益的態(tài)度,,也自然而然地從沮喪突然變得無(wú)所不知,。當(dāng)市盈率達(dá)到20倍,標(biāo)普指數(shù)在2794點(diǎn)時(shí),,每股收益為139.70美元,。深呼吸吧“市場(chǎng)先生”,這與今年早些時(shí)候標(biāo)普指數(shù)處在歷史高點(diǎn)時(shí)的每股收益139.47美元相差無(wú)幾,。就連華爾街的幻想家們也不敢這樣癡心妄想,。
診斷:“市場(chǎng)先生”可能瘋了。
市場(chǎng)跌至低谷時(shí)的111美元每股收益看起來(lái)相當(dāng)合理,,這與經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)家羅伯特·席勒的周期調(diào)整后市盈率水平相當(dāng),。CAPE使用十年平均水平,,消除了利潤(rùn)異常波動(dòng)帶來(lái)的影響。換言之,,CAPE把“市場(chǎng)先生”扮演成了一位性情溫和的紳士。
“市場(chǎng)先生”對(duì)于市盈率的情緒波動(dòng)告訴我們,,2237點(diǎn)最低點(diǎn)與今天的2794點(diǎn)相比,,前者的股票價(jià)格才是更公允的估值。路孚特調(diào)查時(shí)發(fā)現(xiàn),,華爾街分析師預(yù)測(cè)第2季度的每股收益將比去年同期下降19.4%,。但今年晚些時(shí)候或者2021年,每股收益會(huì)出現(xiàn)反彈,。對(duì)于股市而言,,重要的不是它們會(huì)如何反彈,而是在反彈開(kāi)始之后,,它們將穩(wěn)定在什么水平,。
每股收益111美元雖然比歷史最高點(diǎn)減少了五分之一,卻是比較合理的估算,。但這個(gè)數(shù)字也值得警醒,。假如標(biāo)普指數(shù)繼續(xù)將60%的收益用于發(fā)放股息和回購(gòu),并將另外40%進(jìn)行再投資用于企業(yè)發(fā)展,,每股收益將在111美元基礎(chǔ)上每年增長(zhǎng)約5%,。這需要四年半時(shí)間才能重新達(dá)到此前每股140美元的最高點(diǎn)。
在三月末跌入低谷的時(shí)候,,“市場(chǎng)先生”其實(shí)非常理智,。只是他自己不知道而已。(財(cái)富中文網(wǎng))
譯者:Biz
Mister Market is a renowned character created by legendary value investor Benjamin Graham to embody the often erratic, irrational, and unhinged behavior of the overall stock market.
Graham and his disciple, Warren Buffett, relished invoking how Mister Market careens from crazy infatuation that make equities incredibly overpriced to senseless dread that yields bargains to be pounced upon. Between the passions and tantrums, they allowed, Mister Market could show good judgment.
Of course, the way Mister Market values stocks mostly reflects his view of where earnings are headed. Over the past seven weeks, the coronavirus crisis has sent Mister Market lurching through his most extreme mood swings in his recent history, tracing his wildly shifting prognosis for profits.
Is the level of earnings we'll see coming out of the coronavirus downturn the number Mister Market embraced when he was throwing a fit, or the much higher benchmark he's been touting since his outlook suddenly turned sunnier?
Once we judge which of Mister Market's far-apart mindsets make the most sense on earnings, we can establish a reasonable valuation for the stocks.
We'll use the S&P 500 as our proxy for Mister Market. When the S&P hit its all-time high of 3386 on February 19, earnings-per-share, based on four quarters of trailing reported profits, stood at $139.47. Mister Market was jaunty, unreasonably so. The PE ratio was 24.3, 22% higher than the quarter century average of around 20, and earnings were both at historic peak, and near bubble based their super-high share of revenue.
Spooked by the coronavirus outbreak, Mister Market sent the S&P reeling to 2237 on March 23, a rout of 33.9%. At that point, what was Mister Market's outlook on profits, and was he right?
The premium multiple that Mister Market bestowed in mid-February showed serene contentment. The outbreak has made Mister Market less confident about the future. To express that new anxiety, he's applying a lower PE, the norm over recent decades of roughly 20. In that case, at the lows on March 23, Mister Market saw S&P 500 profits stabilizing at $111.18.
After the March 23 bottom, Mister Market shook off his funk, and turned positively euphoric. By the close on April 9, the S&P had recouped half its losses, surging 557 points to 2794, a gain of 25% that ranks as one of the half-dozen largest three-week jumps in history.
Naturally, Mister Market suddenly had turned from despondent to feeling his beans about profits. At our PE of 20, the S&P at 2794 would be earnings $139.70 a share. Take a breath, Mister Market! That's almost identical to the $139.47 stocks garnered at their heights early this year. That's a fantasy that even the Wall Street fantasists aren't selling.
Conclusion: Mister Market may be off his meds.
The $111 number when the market hit the lows looks pretty reasonable. It's similar to the level for economist Robert Shiller's Cyclically Adjusted Price-Earnings ratio, or CAPE, that smooths the erratic swings in profits by using a ten-year average––in other words, casting Mister Market as an even-tempered gentleman.
Mister Market's swings from low to high spirits on earnings tells us that stock prices were more fairly valued at the depths of 2237 than today's 2794. In a poll conducted by Refinitiv, Wall Street analysts forecast a 19.4% drop in Q2 profits versus the same quarter last year. But profits will bounce back, whether the rebound begins in late this year or 2021. What's important for stocks isn't how they jump around, but where they settle when the comeback begins.
Starting at $111, one-fifth off the old highs, is a pretty good estimate. But it's a sobering number. Assuming that the S&P continues to distribute 60% of its profits in dividends and buybacks, and reinvest 40% to grow the business, EPS would rise around 5% a year from that base of $111. From there, it would take four-and-a-half years to rescale the the old pinnacle of $140 per share.
At the point where he plumbed the deep valley in late March, Mister Market was looking sensible. He just didn't know it.